A marketing email converts when a reader on a phone sees who wrote, what's in it for them and what to do next, all in the first screen. Everything else, from type size to button colour to how many links you add, either helps that first screen or gets in its way. These are the 12 design rules we rebuilt all 35 MailInApp starter templates on in November 2026, with the numbers we measured before and after, so you can apply them to any email you write.
The anatomy of a marketing email that converts
Most good marketing emails follow the same order from top to bottom. Readers learn it quickly, so a familiar order helps them find the offer and the button without thinking:
- Logo header: one centred logo.
- Hero: a short headline, one or two sentences, a picture and the main action.
- Body: one to three blocks, such as the details, a short list of benefits or a customer's quote.
- Closing call to action: the same action again, for readers who scroll to the end.
- Footer: your address and the unsubscribe link.
- Logo headerTells readers who wrote, in one look.
- HeroHeadline, one or two sentences, a picture and the main action.
- BodyOne to three blocks: the details, benefits and a customer's quote.
- Closing call to actionThe same action again, for readers who scroll to the end.
- FooterYour address and the unsubscribe link.
| Part | What it does |
|---|---|
| Logo header | Tells readers who wrote, in one look. |
| Hero | Headline, one or two sentences, a picture and the main action. |
| Body | One to three blocks: the details, benefits and a customer's quote. |
| Closing call to action | The same action again, for readers who scroll to the end. |
| Footer | Your address and the unsubscribe link. |
| Part | What it does |
|---|---|
| Logo header | Tells readers who wrote, in one look. |
| Headline and action | One headline, one sentence and the action, with no picture. |
| Footer | Your address and the unsubscribe link. |
Short emails skip parts. A postcard keeps only the logo, a headline with one sentence, the action and the footer, so the whole email fits on about one phone screen. It suits a flash sale, a cart reminder or a one-question survey, where the ask is obvious and a picture would only push the button down.
1. Start with a logo header
The first thing a reader checks is who sent the email. A centred logo answers that in one look and makes the email feel like the rest of your brand. Keep it to one logo, with no tagline column beside it: on a phone, a two-column header shrinks both sides.
If your logo is dark, give it a light version for dark mode, or it can turn faint on a dark background. Our dark mode guide explains which email apps recolour your email and how to plan for them.
2. Put the headline, picture and action in the first screen
On a phone, the first screen is roughly the first 700px of the email. Your headline, a sentence of detail, the picture and the main button should all start there. Readers who never scroll still see the offer and the way to act on it.
Write the headline benefit first and short: eight words or fewer in English. Keep the headline as real text, never baked into the picture. Text in a picture vanishes when images are off, can't be translated and can't be read by a screen reader.
When we measured our starters at phone width, 27 of 35 had their main action in the first 700px. After rebuilding them on the blueprint, all 35 did.
Main action in the first screen (700px)
Median email height on a phone
| Measure | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Main action in the first screen | 27 of 35 | 35 of 35 |
| Median email height on a phone | 963px | 1,415px |
3. Let the interactive block be the action
In an interactive email, the button often isn't the goal. In a survey, the goal is the answer; in an invitation, it's the RSVP. Put that block in the hero, where a button would go: the rating right under a survey's headline, the RSVP under an event's date and place, the coupon in a flash sale. One tap inside the email beats a click to a web page and a second tap there.
4. Close with the same action
Readers who scroll to the end have read everything and are ready to act. Give them a tinted band with one line and the same action as the hero, with the same label. Don't introduce a new offer at the bottom.
When the action can only happen once, such as a vote or an RSVP, the closing button can open the email in the browser instead, where the same block waits.
5. Size text for phones: 18px body, 36px headlines
Small text is the most common reason a good email is hard to read on a phone. Our starters use 18px body text with a line height of 1.5, 36px headlines (30px on phones, so long words in German or Arabic don't break into four lines), 26px subheadings and 14px only for captions and legal text.
Before
Fresh roast, ready to ship
Our autumn blend is back for two weeks only.
Shop nowAfter
Fresh roast, ready to ship
Our autumn blend is back for two weeks only.
Shop now- Headline
- 28px → 36px
- Body
- 16px → 18px
- Button height
- 37px → 54px
| Element | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Headline | 28px | 36px |
| Body | 16px | 18px |
| Button height | 37px | 54px |
6. Make buttons big enough for a thumb
A button should be at least 52px tall and 280px wide on a computer, and as wide as the screen on a phone. That clears the WCAG 2.2 minimum target size with room to spare, and a full-width button is impossible to miss. Keep the label short and specific: two to four words that say what happens next.
7. Give the button its own colour
If your buttons share the colour of every heading and band, nothing tells the eye where to land. Pick a call-to-action colour that clearly stands apart from your brand colour, and keep white text on it at a contrast of at least 4.5:1 (WCAG 1.4.3), in light and dark mode.
- SageShop nowContrast✓ 5.0:1
- InkShop nowContrast✓ 5.2:1
- CoralShop nowContrast✓ 5.5:1
- MidnightShop nowContrast✓ 5.2:1
| Palette | Brand colour | Action colour | White text contrast |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sage | #3f6b4f | #b45309 | 5.0:1 |
| Ink | #1f2937 | #2563eb | 5.2:1 |
| Coral | #c2410c | #0f766e | 5.5:1 |
| Midnight | #312e81 | #c2410c | 5.2:1 |
8. Use one column for text
Three columns of small text read badly on a computer and stack into a long scroll on a phone. Keep text in a single column. The exception is product cards: a two-up grid of pictures, names and prices stacks cleanly on a phone, so it's fine.
9. Write short paragraphs and bold the key fact
Keep each paragraph to two sentences at most, about three lines on a phone. Then bold the one fact a skimmer must catch: the discount, the date, the deadline. Readers scan before they read, and bold text is what they stop on.
10. Ask for one thing
Use at most two different actions: the main one and, if you need it, one secondary link such as "View in store". The closing band repeats the main action, so it doesn't count. Every extra link splits attention.
Match the label to the commitment. For a newsletter, a lesson or a survey, use a low-commitment label like "Read the story" or "Take the quiz". For a sale, say it directly: "Shop the sale".
11. Add social proof
A short customer quote, a star rating or one strong number tells readers that other people already said yes. Place it in the body, after the hero, where it supports the decision instead of delaying the action. One piece is enough. If your store collects reviews, MailInApp's store reviews block can show real ones.
12. Write a preview text that finishes the subject
The preview text (or preheader) is the line inbox apps show after the subject. Write 40 to 90 characters that complete the subject rather than repeat the headline. Left blank, many apps fill it with the first words of the email, which is often a logo's alt text or "View in browser".
What about email length?
The research disagrees. Buttondown found no link between length and click rate across its newsletters, and Email on Acid warns that its own length tests shouldn't be read as a standard. So we treat length as a limit, not a target: a standard email stays under 2,000px on a phone and a postcard under 900px. The first screen matters far more than the last.
Skip decorative animated GIFs, too. Classic Outlook shows only the first frame, and every extra image slows the email down. A live countdown, a carousel or a scratch card gives you movement that also does a job.
Two real examples
These are two MailInApp starters rendered exactly as they're mailed, one standard and one postcard. Check them against the rules: the logo first, the action in the first screen, bold key facts, one action repeated at the end, and a preview text that finishes the subject.
Subject
Meet our new small-batch roast
Preview text
Small-batch, fresh from the roaster and shipping this week.
Subject
How did we do?
Preview text
One tap is all it takes, and we read every answer.
Scroll inside the phone to read the whole email.
Accessibility and dark mode
Every rule above also makes the email easier to use with assistive technology: real text instead of text in pictures, alt text on every image, enough contrast and targets big enough to tap. Our accessible interactive email checklist covers the rest. For colours, read what breaks in dark mode, and for which email apps show which features, see the email client report.
How MailInApp applies these rules
You don't have to remember all 12. In MailInApp:
- Every starter template is built on this blueprint, with the type scale, button size, call-to-action colour and a preview text already set. Postcards and plain transactional emails are there for shorter messages.
- The Logo header and Hero sections in the Insert panel's Sections tab start a new email on the same layout, with your brand kit's logo.
- Pre-Flight warns you when the first action comes late, when an email links to too many places, or when body text is under 16px, along with its contrast, alt text and dark mode checks.
- Mia, the AI assistant, follows the same blueprint when it builds a new email for you.
The design tips in the templates guide sum up the writing rules in one place.
Sources
- MailInApp's own measurements of its 35 starter templates at 375px wide in Chromium, before and after the rebuild, November 2026.
- W3C: Understanding SC 2.5.8 Target Size (Minimum)
- W3C: Understanding SC 1.4.3 Contrast (Minimum)
- Buttondown: Email length doesn't affect click rate
- Email on Acid: Ideal email length